We Hired the Experts: Why That Argument Failed After the Fort Street Facade Collapse

The AJ Bristow verdict shows that engaging a specialist subcontractor changes your duty but never removes it.

On 5 August 2022 a subcontracted stonemason was cutting out mortar beneath two large sandstone blocks in the facade of a building at Fort Street High School in Petersham. The blocks fell forward and crushed him against the scaffold. He died. Heritage builder AJ Bristow & Sons pleaded not guilty. On 9 November, after a hearing that ran over several months, the NSW Industrial Court found it guilty of a Category 2 offence. Sentencing directions are listed for today, 19 November.

"We Hired the Experts" Is Not a Defence

The part of this decision that every head contractor should read is the argument that failed. The builder said it could rely on the specialist heritage expertise of its stonemasonry subcontractor. Stonework on a heritage facade is niche. The subcontractor knew the craft. Surely the builder was entitled to leave the technical decisions to them?

Taylor J, President, rejected that argument. The court found that whether or not the builder was the principal contractor, it had at least a concurrent duty. The main failure was not ensuring the stones were propped after the brick parapet above them was removed. Her Honour also addressed hindsight bias directly, which tells you the defence tried to argue the risk only looked obvious after the event.

Engaging a specialist is a sensible thing to do. It just does not take your own duty off the table. It changes what your duty looks like.

What a Concurrent Duty Asks of You

When two or more businesses share a duty, each must discharge it to the extent it has the capacity to influence and control the matter. A builder who controls the sequence of works, the removal of a parapet and the scaffold has plenty of influence. It cannot hand that influence to someone else by contract.

Ask yourself:

  • When a specialist subcontractor starts work, who in your business reviews their method for structural stability?
  • Do you know which of your own activities, like demolition or removing supports, change the risk for the trade that follows?
  • Is there a hold point before a specialist starts work beneath anything that might move?
  • Have you asked the specialist the simple question: "what is holding this up while you work?"

The Same Theme Runs Through This Week's Brief

Bristow is not an isolated case. In North Wollongong, Civil 1 supplied plant and workers for piling work when a reinforcement cage buckled and fell onto 11,000 volt power lines. It was fined $238,000 on 6 November. The principal contractor had already been fined $300,000 over the same incident earlier this year. Two businesses, one incident, two penalties.

The NSW Resources Regulator now lists proceedings against three companies over the 2024 death of a contract worker who fell through a shaft cover during decommissioning of the Austar Coal Mine near Paxton. Those are allegations only. But the pattern is plain. Regulators look at every business with a hand in the work.

And in South Australia, principal contractor Smart Built asked for props to be removed from 10 metre precast panels because they restricted site access. Thirteen days later three panels weighing about 30 tonnes fell onto the neighbouring home. Temporary support again. Removed again without engineering sign-off.

Coordination Is a Written Thing

The duty to consult, cooperate and coordinate with other duty holders is easy to treat as a courtesy. Cases like these show it is the mechanism by which shared duties are actually met. A conversation at the gate is not enough. You need a record of who will check what and when.

  • Agree in writing who verifies temporary support before work continues underneath.
  • Make the removal of any support, prop or parapet a hold point that needs sign-off.
  • Keep the specialist's method on file and record that someone in your team reviewed it.

If the specialist on your next job got it wrong, what evidence would show that your business did its own part rather than simply trusting theirs?